- What We Do
- Agriculture and Food Security
- Democracy, Human Rights and Governance
- Economic Growth and Trade
- Ending Extreme Poverty
- Environment and Global Climate Change
- Gender Equality and Women's Empowerment
- Global Health
- Science, Technology and Innovation
- Development Innovation Ventures
- Data & Analytics for Development
- Frontiers in Development
- Grand Challenges for Development
- Higher Education Solutions Network (HESN)
- International Research & Science Programs
- Leveraging Universities
- Mobile Solutions
- Pioneers Prize
- Research and Innovation Fellowships
- Science at USAID
- Tech Challenge for Atrocity Prevention
- Water and Sanitation
- Working in Crises and Conflict
$291,154 | Stage 2: Testing at Scale | Global Health
The problem: Frequently fatal traffic accidents on minibuses
“14 Killed in Crash” is an all too common headline in Kenya, where a ride on a minibus is a notorious danger. In sub-Saharan Africa, road deaths are the leading cause of death for people ages 15 to 29 and the second leading cause of death for people ages 5 to 14. Road deaths cost the region $10 billion annually. Solutions to this road safety problem, like building guardrails or traffic enforcement, however, are often extremely expensive.
The solution: Saving lives with stickers
A pair of Georgetown University researchers devised an experiment to see if simple messaging could help save passengers’ lives. Motivational messages encouraging passengers to “Speak up!” against dangerous driving were pasted in the passenger cabin of minibuses. The passengers were not asked to report the drivers to a third party—they were simply encouraged to insist that their drivers slow down.
The researchers’ pilot study, which involved 2,400 vehicles, showed striking results: the stickers were posted inside a random selection of 1200 minibuses. Compared to rates for 1200 buses without stickers, road accident insurance claims fell by half, and claims involving injury or death dropped by two-thirds. The cost was $7 per disability-adjusted life year.
To encourage drivers to keep the stickers in place on buses, the researchers ran a weekly lottery with winnings of $60 (equivalent to roughly one week’s wages). Drivers were eligible to receive the prize if they had retained the stickers in their vehicles.
The potential: Cost-effectiveness, impacts and implications
With $290,000 from IDEA/DIV, the researchers are expanding the pilot to reach approximately 10,000 minibuses in Kenya. Researchers are testing different messages and different media techniques to gauge the effectiveness of each over time.
It is estimated that there are over 40,000 minibuses operating in urban and rural areas of Kenya. More than 300,000 people take public transportation every day. If the results of the pilot expansion are as promising as the initial results, Kenya’s leading insurance company for minibuses is ready fund and scale the campaign as it will both increase profits and save lives.
- Read the results of the original “Heckle and Chide” study
- Meet lead authors Dr. James Habyarimana and Dr. Billy Jack
- See what the NY Times Freakonomics Blog had to say
- Learn more from the WHO about the problem of road traffic injuries
Last updated: October 15, 2013